During a Yachtmaster preparation course a few months back, two of the three candidates were well up to the required standard and both passed. The third came to me with misgivings on the Wednesday, saying that he was not happy about his boat handling and thought he should have more practice before taking the assessment. I thought he was up to the required standard and told him so. I seem to have given the chap confidence, so he said he would have a go at the exam. We had, in fairness to this candidate, some strong winds during the Monday and Tuesday of the preparation week and it had not been easy to park the boat on finger pontoons with a strong cross wind; but the other two had managed successfully. The third candidate had made two Atlantic crossings and had spent most of his time in either the Mediterranean or Caribbean, he had been crew and mate of a large charter yacht, but had rarely been behind the helm for close quarter manoevres, and was understandably a little lacking in confidence in strong tide and wind conditions.
The examiner arrived on board and candidate 3 decided to be first with the assessment. A safety briefing was given, followed by preparing a passage plan to take us from Gosport to Cowes, setting off about 9.30 pm. The examiner ordered that the GPS be turned off.
The first point I would like to emphasize here is that a Yachtmaster is not expected to buoy hop down the Solent to get from A to B. Reduction of soundings exercises should be carried out to ascertain the rise of tide at a particular time. A Yachtmaster then can see if there is sufficient water over a shallow which will allow him to cut a corner safely and, if needs be, save time on passage. He should then be able to shape a course to his destination, providing there is sufficient water over the shallows. By all means use buoys to help on position finding and to help keep a check on progress. The trouble with candidate 3 was that he followed the ferry route out of Portsmouth harbour when we were close to HW; he took as his departure point one of the port hand buoys close to the small boat channel, but failed to make a log entry of time, log reading and course steered. Not being familiar with the Solent, the candidate then started heading for the north beacon off Wootton Creek thinking it was north Sturbridge, the two are in fact nearly three miles apart. Shortly after that he admitted he was lost.
I have always encouraged any navigator who is lost or confused to stop the boat and gain time to gather his thoughts. This can be by heaving to, putting down the anchor or taking down the sails and motoring into wind or tide so that there is the least amount of speed over the ground. This the candidate sensibly did, but was a trifle nonplussed with being lost and having difficulty in locating lights which could be recognized on the chart.
See my tips on the man overboard procedure we practiced.